Advertisement
ACCUEIL arrow TOP ET FLOP ALBUMS
TOP ET FLOP ALBUMS Convertir en PDF Version imprimable Suggérer par mail
Écrit par Administrator   
21-10-2006

Dans la jungle des nouveautés, il est parfois dur de si retrouver pour les lecteurs occasionnels, voici donc une rubrique nommée on aime ou on n'aime pas qui je l'espère vous aidera dans vos choix !

NOTE IMPORTANTE : Il s'agit de mon avis personnel sur un album, ce qui ne remet pas en cause les auteurs ni ce qu'il on pu faire avant ou après, ni d'une critique d'album. Mais dans la vie il faut savoir trancher entre le bon et le moins bon !!

 

 

 
 Sans être très novateur sur le thème, cette BD m'a beaucoup plus j'y retrouve le Berthet que j'aime avec une histoire simple efficace et qui se laisse lire avec plaisir. Un bon moment de distraction.
 C'est beau, c'est intelligent, avec de très bonnes réflexions sur notre société et quelques audaces graphiques bien senties comme la scène de mort du père. UN MUST à découvrir d'urgence. Pour les fans, il s'agit de la fille de l'héroine de l'ivresse du poulpe.

 Hum, comment dire, le trait est léger, les dialogues sont pleins de subtilités avec un langage châtié et raffiné. ;) Bon vous l'avez devinez, c'est du très bon KRAN l'un des meilleurs tomes. A mourir.... de rire !

 Un très beau 1er album, avec un scénario intéressant et une bonne intrigue, un dessin bien léché. Cette BD est très agréable à lire
 Les sous-sols du révolu est à classer dans les albums mythiques. Graphiquement exceptionnel avec des aplats noirs et du gris en relief bref un album à posséder ! Marc-Antoine Mathieu au mieux de sa forme, une  balade stupéfiante dans les entrailles du Louvre
Pour finir une tès belle BD en noir et blanc mélant western et sf avec un scénario très original et un graphisme brillant a lire d'urgence
   
 Pourtant fan de Munuera et Morvan, mais aussi fan de Spirou qui m'a fait découvrir la BD, je dois avouer que ce tome m'a laissé de marbre et que je n'ai ressenti aucun plaisir à sa lecture contrairement au précédent à suivre donc...Toutefois cet album pourra plaire aux plus jeunes lecteurs.


Ce hors-série a le mérite de caler le coffret offert avec le tome 4. Question contenu, je trouve ça très léger et il reprend des visuels d'exlibris vus et revus bref pas grand chose à se mettre sous la dent dommage car cette série exceptionnelle méritait mieux ! 
   
   
Dernière mise à jour : ( 13-02-2007 )
 
73 queries executed
1
SELECT folder, element, published, params
 FROM jos_mambots
 WHERE published >= 1
 AND access <= 0
 AND folder = 'system'
 ORDER BY ordering
2 SELECT template FROM jos_templates_menu WHERE client_id = 0 AND ( menuid = 0 OR menuid = 244 ) ORDER BY menuid DESC LIMIT 1
3 DELETE FROM jos_session WHERE ( ( time < '1283907218' ) AND guest = 0 AND gid > 0 ) OR ( ( time < '1283907218' ) AND guest = 1 AND userid = 0 )
4 SELECT * FROM jos_session WHERE session_id = '5ef69eaa48727b1a9197646f204f63bb'
5 SELECT session_id FROM jos_session WHERE session_id = 'e30633958ac93b5a184283908ebd7188'
6 INSERT INTO jos_session ( `session_id`,`time`,`username`,`gid`,`guest` ) VALUES ( 'e30633958ac93b5a184283908ebd7188','1283908118','','0','1' )
7 SELECT * FROM jos_menu WHERE id = 244
8 SELECT a.*, u.name AS author, u.usertype, cc.name AS category, s.name AS section, g.name AS groups, s.published AS sec_pub, cc.published AS cat_pub, s.access AS sec_access, cc.access AS cat_access, s.id AS sec_id, cc.id as cat_id FROM jos_content AS a LEFT JOIN jos_categories AS cc ON cc.id = a.catid LEFT JOIN jos_sections AS s ON s.id = cc.section AND s.scope = 'content' LEFT JOIN jos_users AS u ON u.id = a.created_by LEFT JOIN jos_groups AS g ON a.access = g.id WHERE a.id = 203 AND ( a.state = 1 OR a.state = -1 ) AND ( a.publish_up = '0000-00-00 00:00:00' OR a.publish_up <= '2010-09-08 03:08' ) AND ( a.publish_down = '0000-00-00 00:00:00' OR a.publish_down >= '2010-09-08 03:08' ) AND a.access <= 0
9 SELECT a.id FROM jos_content AS a WHERE a.catid = 102 AND a.state = 1 AND a.access <= 0 AND ( a.state = 1 OR a.state = -1 ) AND ( a.publish_up = '0000-00-00 00:00:00' OR a.publish_up <= '2010-09-08 03:08' ) AND ( a.publish_down = '0000-00-00 00:00:00' OR a.publish_down >= '2010-09-08 03:08' ) ORDER BY a.ordering
10 UPDATE jos_content SET hits = ( hits + 1 ) WHERE id = '203'
11 SELECT folder, element, published, params FROM jos_mambots WHERE access <= 0 AND folder = 'content' ORDER BY ordering
12 SELECT a.* FROM jos_components AS a WHERE ( a.admin_menu_link = 'option=com_syndicate' OR a.admin_menu_link = 'option=com_syndicate&hidemainmenu=1' ) AND a.option = 'com_syndicate'
13 SELECT COUNT(*) AS numrows FROM jos_banner WHERE showBanner = 1
14 SELECT * FROM jos_banner WHERE showBanner = 1 LIMIT 1, 1
15 UPDATE jos_banner SET impmade = impmade + 1 WHERE bid = 2
16 SELECT id, title, module, position, content, showtitle, params FROM jos_modules AS m INNER JOIN jos_modules_menu AS mm ON mm.moduleid = m.id WHERE m.published = 1 AND m.access <= 0 AND m.client_id != 1 AND ( mm.menuid = 0 OR mm.menuid = 244 ) ORDER BY ordering
17 SELECT id FROM jos_menu WHERE link = 'index.php?option=com_search' AND published = 1
18 SELECT id, name, link, parent, type, menutype, access FROM jos_menu WHERE published = 1 AND access <= 0 ORDER BY menutype, parent, ordering
19 SELECT m.* FROM jos_menu AS m WHERE menutype = 'mainmenu' AND published = 1 AND access <= 0 ORDER BY parent, ordering
20 SELECT COUNT( id ) FROM jos_menu WHERE type = 'content_item_link' AND published = 1
21 SELECT id FROM jos_menu WHERE type = 'content_item_link' AND published = 1 AND link = 'index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=203'
22 SELECT id FROM jos_menu WHERE type = 'content_item_link' AND published = 1 AND link = 'index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=204'
23 SELECT m.* FROM jos_menu AS m WHERE menutype = 'othermenu' AND published = 1 AND access <= 0 ORDER BY parent, ordering
24 SELECT * FROM jos_content WHERE id = '206'
25 SELECT ms.id AS sid, ms.type AS stype, mc.id AS cid, mc.type AS ctype, i.id as sectionid, i.id As catid, ms.published AS spub, mc.published AS cpub FROM jos_content AS i LEFT JOIN jos_sections AS s ON i.sectionid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS ms ON ms.componentid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_categories AS c ON i.catid = c.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS mc ON mc.componentid = c.id WHERE ( ms.type IN ( 'content_section', 'content_blog_section' ) OR mc.type IN ( 'content_blog_category', 'content_category' ) ) AND i.id = 206 ORDER BY ms.type DESC, mc.type DESC, ms.id, mc.id
26 SELECT id FROM jos_menu WHERE type = 'content_blog_section' AND published = 1 AND componentid = 0
27 SELECT id FROM jos_menu WHERE type = 'content_blog_category' AND published = 1 AND componentid = 0
28 SELECT * FROM jos_content WHERE id = '202'
29 SELECT ms.id AS sid, ms.type AS stype, mc.id AS cid, mc.type AS ctype, i.id as sectionid, i.id As catid, ms.published AS spub, mc.published AS cpub FROM jos_content AS i LEFT JOIN jos_sections AS s ON i.sectionid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS ms ON ms.componentid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_categories AS c ON i.catid = c.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS mc ON mc.componentid = c.id WHERE ( ms.type IN ( 'content_section', 'content_blog_section' ) OR mc.type IN ( 'content_blog_category', 'content_category' ) ) AND i.id = 202 ORDER BY ms.type DESC, mc.type DESC, ms.id, mc.id
30 SELECT * FROM jos_content WHERE id = '198'
31 SELECT ms.id AS sid, ms.type AS stype, mc.id AS cid, mc.type AS ctype, i.id as sectionid, i.id As catid, ms.published AS spub, mc.published AS cpub FROM jos_content AS i LEFT JOIN jos_sections AS s ON i.sectionid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS ms ON ms.componentid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_categories AS c ON i.catid = c.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS mc ON mc.componentid = c.id WHERE ( ms.type IN ( 'content_section', 'content_blog_section' ) OR mc.type IN ( 'content_blog_category', 'content_category' ) ) AND i.id = 198 ORDER BY ms.type DESC, mc.type DESC, ms.id, mc.id
32 SELECT * FROM jos_content WHERE id = '195'
33 SELECT ms.id AS sid, ms.type AS stype, mc.id AS cid, mc.type AS ctype, i.id as sectionid, i.id As catid, ms.published AS spub, mc.published AS cpub FROM jos_content AS i LEFT JOIN jos_sections AS s ON i.sectionid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS ms ON ms.componentid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_categories AS c ON i.catid = c.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS mc ON mc.componentid = c.id WHERE ( ms.type IN ( 'content_section', 'content_blog_section' ) OR mc.type IN ( 'content_blog_category', 'content_category' ) ) AND i.id = 195 ORDER BY ms.type DESC, mc.type DESC, ms.id, mc.id
34 SELECT * FROM jos_content WHERE id = '194'
35 SELECT ms.id AS sid, ms.type AS stype, mc.id AS cid, mc.type AS ctype, i.id as sectionid, i.id As catid, ms.published AS spub, mc.published AS cpub FROM jos_content AS i LEFT JOIN jos_sections AS s ON i.sectionid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS ms ON ms.componentid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_categories AS c ON i.catid = c.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS mc ON mc.componentid = c.id WHERE ( ms.type IN ( 'content_section', 'content_blog_section' ) OR mc.type IN ( 'content_blog_category', 'content_category' ) ) AND i.id = 194 ORDER BY ms.type DESC, mc.type DESC, ms.id, mc.id
36 SELECT * FROM jos_content WHERE id = '193'
37 SELECT ms.id AS sid, ms.type AS stype, mc.id AS cid, mc.type AS ctype, i.id as sectionid, i.id As catid, ms.published AS spub, mc.published AS cpub FROM jos_content AS i LEFT JOIN jos_sections AS s ON i.sectionid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS ms ON ms.componentid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_categories AS c ON i.catid = c.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS mc ON mc.componentid = c.id WHERE ( ms.type IN ( 'content_section', 'content_blog_section' ) OR mc.type IN ( 'content_blog_category', 'content_category' ) ) AND i.id = 193 ORDER BY ms.type DESC, mc.type DESC, ms.id, mc.id
38 SELECT * FROM jos_content WHERE id = '192'
39 SELECT ms.id AS sid, ms.type AS stype, mc.id AS cid, mc.type AS ctype, i.id as sectionid, i.id As catid, ms.published AS spub, mc.published AS cpub FROM jos_content AS i LEFT JOIN jos_sections AS s ON i.sectionid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS ms ON ms.componentid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_categories AS c ON i.catid = c.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS mc ON mc.componentid = c.id WHERE ( ms.type IN ( 'content_section', 'content_blog_section' ) OR mc.type IN ( 'content_blog_category', 'content_category' ) ) AND i.id = 192 ORDER BY ms.type DESC, mc.type DESC, ms.id, mc.id
40 SELECT * FROM jos_content WHERE id = '191'
41 SELECT ms.id AS sid, ms.type AS stype, mc.id AS cid, mc.type AS ctype, i.id as sectionid, i.id As catid, ms.published AS spub, mc.published AS cpub FROM jos_content AS i LEFT JOIN jos_sections AS s ON i.sectionid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS ms ON ms.componentid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_categories AS c ON i.catid = c.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS mc ON mc.componentid = c.id WHERE ( ms.type IN ( 'content_section', 'content_blog_section' ) OR mc.type IN ( 'content_blog_category', 'content_category' ) ) AND i.id = 191 ORDER BY ms.type DESC, mc.type DESC, ms.id, mc.id
42 SELECT * FROM jos_content WHERE id = '190'
43 SELECT ms.id AS sid, ms.type AS stype, mc.id AS cid, mc.type AS ctype, i.id as sectionid, i.id As catid, ms.published AS spub, mc.published AS cpub FROM jos_content AS i LEFT JOIN jos_sections AS s ON i.sectionid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS ms ON ms.componentid = s.id LEFT JOIN jos_categories AS c ON i.catid = c.id LEFT JOIN jos_menu AS mc ON mc.componentid = c.id WHERE ( ms.type IN ( 'content_section', 'content_blog_section' ) OR mc.type IN ( 'content_blog_category', 'content_category' ) ) AND i.id = 190 ORDER BY ms.type DESC, mc.type DESC, ms.id, mc.id
44 SELECT jos_menu.id FROM jos_menu WHERE jos_menu.link = 'index.php?option=com_zoom'
45 SELECT COUNT(*) as COUNTER FROM jos_zoomfiles jos_zoomfiles, jos_zoom jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoomfiles.catid = jos_zoom.catid AND jos_zoomfiles.published=1 AND jos_zoom.catpassword = '' AND jos_zoom.catmembers = '1' AND (jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpeg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%gif%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%png%') AND jos_zoom.catid != 66666 LIMIT 5
46 SELECT COUNT(*) as COUNTER FROM jos_zoomfiles jos_zoomfiles, jos_zoom jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoomfiles.catid = jos_zoom.catid AND jos_zoomfiles.published=1 AND jos_zoom.catpassword = '' AND jos_zoom.catmembers = '1' AND (jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpeg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%gif%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%png%') AND jos_zoom.catid != 66666 ORDER BY rand() LIMIT 5
47 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgid FROM jos_zoomfiles jos_zoomfiles, jos_zoom jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoomfiles.catid = jos_zoom.catid AND jos_zoomfiles.published=1 AND jos_zoom.catpassword = '' AND jos_zoom.catmembers = '1' AND (jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpeg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%gif%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%png%') AND jos_zoom.catid != 66666 ORDER BY rand() LIMIT 5
48 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.catid FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 28
49 SELECT jos_zoom.catdir FROM jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoom.catid = 1
50 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 28
51 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgid FROM jos_zoomfiles jos_zoomfiles, jos_zoom jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoomfiles.catid = jos_zoom.catid AND jos_zoomfiles.published=1 AND jos_zoom.catpassword = '' AND jos_zoom.catmembers = '1' AND (jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpeg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%gif%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%png%') AND jos_zoom.catid != 66666 AND jos_zoom.catid ='1' ORDER BY imgdate ASC
52 SELECT jos_zoom.catdir FROM jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoom.catid = 1
53 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 28
54 SELECT jos_zoom.catname FROM jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoom.catid = 1
55 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imghits FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 28
56 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgid FROM jos_zoomfiles jos_zoomfiles, jos_zoom jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoomfiles.catid = jos_zoom.catid AND jos_zoomfiles.published=1 AND jos_zoom.catpassword = '' AND jos_zoom.catmembers = '1' AND (jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpeg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%gif%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%png%') AND jos_zoom.catid != 66666 ORDER BY rand() LIMIT 5
57 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.catid FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 22
58 SELECT jos_zoom.catdir FROM jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoom.catid = 1
59 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 22
60 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgid FROM jos_zoomfiles jos_zoomfiles, jos_zoom jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoomfiles.catid = jos_zoom.catid AND jos_zoomfiles.published=1 AND jos_zoom.catpassword = '' AND jos_zoom.catmembers = '1' AND (jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpeg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%gif%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%png%') AND jos_zoom.catid != 66666 AND jos_zoom.catid ='1' ORDER BY imgdate ASC
61 SELECT jos_zoom.catdir FROM jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoom.catid = 1
62 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 22
63 SELECT jos_zoom.catname FROM jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoom.catid = 1
64 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imghits FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 22
65 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgid FROM jos_zoomfiles jos_zoomfiles, jos_zoom jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoomfiles.catid = jos_zoom.catid AND jos_zoomfiles.published=1 AND jos_zoom.catpassword = '' AND jos_zoom.catmembers = '1' AND (jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpeg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%gif%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%png%') AND jos_zoom.catid != 66666 ORDER BY rand() LIMIT 5
66 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.catid FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 22
67 SELECT jos_zoom.catdir FROM jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoom.catid = 1
68 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 22
69 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgid FROM jos_zoomfiles jos_zoomfiles, jos_zoom jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoomfiles.catid = jos_zoom.catid AND jos_zoomfiles.published=1 AND jos_zoom.catpassword = '' AND jos_zoom.catmembers = '1' AND (jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%jpeg%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%gif%' OR jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename LIKE '%png%') AND jos_zoom.catid != 66666 AND jos_zoom.catid ='1' ORDER BY imgdate ASC
70 SELECT jos_zoom.catdir FROM jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoom.catid = 1
71 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imgfilename FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 22
72 SELECT jos_zoom.catname FROM jos_zoom WHERE jos_zoom.catid = 1
73 SELECT jos_zoomfiles.imghits FROM jos_zoomfiles WHERE jos_zoomfiles.imgid = 22